Britain’s First Female Sharia Judge says “We Can’t Ask Muslims NOT to Have More than One Wife”

Does anyone actually still believe that Sharia Law can coexist with our system of Constitutional law? If you happen to run into someone who still believe this fantasy, have them take a look to the East and notice what is happening in Europe — particularly in the UK, where the government has given limited ability for Sharia courts to operate in Muslim communities.

As the Muslim population grows, more and more young Muslims are eschewing the legal means of marriage and embracing Sharia weddings.

As many as 100,000 couples are living in such marriages, which are not valid under UK law, and bypassing register offices, experts said. Ministers have raised fears that women can be left without the right to a fair share of assets if the relationship ends, while others are forced to return to abusive “husbands”.


Trending: Toronto Mayor: No More Asylum Seekers!

This new trend is also giving rise to another particularly Muslim (though there are other cultures who practice this) tradition – polygamy.

A leading Islamic family lawyer warned that the increase in Sharia ceremonies among the 2.7 million-strong Muslim population in Britain was also behind a growth in “secret polygamy”.

“Probably a quarter of all couples I see involve polygamy issues,” Aina Khan told The Times. “There has been a huge rise in recent years because people can have a secret nikah [Islamic marriage] and no one will know about it.”

 sharia courtThe growth in a parallel marriage system that bypassed the register office was being driven by Muslims aged below 30, who were becoming more religious, she said. Other factors include finding a way around the expectation of no sex before marriage and a fear of British family courts, which presume that assets should be split equally.


The rise in polygamy and Sharia marriages can be attributed to a couple of factors. First, young British Muslims are becoming more religious and the trend is leading them to live more faithfully to the cultural norms in the Islamic world. Secondly, the Sharia courts, which are supposed to operate inside Britain’s legal system, have been working outside British law in allowing these unregistered marriages. (One wonders where else these courts might be disregarding British law to allow religious Muslims to live as they choose and in direct opposition to the law.)

One such example of what is happening in the UK comes to us from Sharia judge Amra Bone (who is the UK’s first female Sharia judge). Bone recently said that “the government cannot — ask Muslims not to have more than one wife. People have a right to decide for themselves,” meaning that she believes that Muslims in Britain don’t have to obey the laws of the nation because the Sharia law is of greater consequence.

The British were foolish to believe that the Sharia courts could coexist with British law, and the weakest in Britain’s Muslim society are now paying the price. Any attempt at integrating Islamic religious law into Western culture and law will end disastrously because the philosophies governing each are in diametric opposition. They are like oil and water; they cannot coexist in the same space – you either have Sharia law or you have Western civic law. You cannot have both.

The views expressed in this opinion article are solely those of their author and are not necessarily either shared or endorsed by

Join the conversation!

We have no tolerance for comments containing violence, racism, vulgarity, profanity, all caps, or discourteous behavior. Thank you for partnering with us to maintain a courteous and useful public environment where we can engage in reasonable discourse.

Do NOT follow this link or you will be banned from the site!

Send this to a friend