College Bans Christian Songs from their Holiday “Unity Tree” Ceremony

An all-female Christian a cappella group at James Madison University (JMU) was told it couldn’t sing “Mary, Did You Know?” at the school’s “unity tree” lighting because it represents a specific religion. 

JMU said it decided to ban Christian songs from the celebration because administrators did not want to promote a specific religion at a public university event. That’s one of the reasons why the tree was named a “unity tree.” Instead, the members of the a cappella group, Into Hymn, were told they could sign a list or pre-approved secular songs. 

Bizarrely, a few days later, the university hosted its first on-campus menorah lighting, a 12-foot tall display. A strange double-standard–if a traditional Christmas song is a state endorsement of Christianity, what does the menorah constitute?

take our poll - story continues below

Who should replace Nikki Haley as our ambassador to the U.N.?

  • Who should replace Nikki Haley as our ambassador to the U.N.?  

  • This field is for validation purposes and should be left unchanged.
Completing this poll grants you access to Eagle Rising updates free of charge. You may opt out at anytime. You also agree to this site's Privacy Policy and Terms of Use.

Learn more below:

Into Hymn, a Christian a cappella group at James Madison University, was not allowed to sing “Mary, Did You Know?” at an annual campus tree lighting ceremony on Friday.

According to The Breeze, the Student Government Association at JMU told the a cappella group they were only allowed to sing secular songs. Michaela Kim, a member of Into Hymn, said the group received an email days before their performance with a list of approved songs, which excluded all religious hymns.

“We represent the Christian faith; that is what our music is all about,” Kim said.

However, the group was told they could not sing “Mary, Did You Know?” because it represents a specific religion.

Kim said the group did not have enough time to prepare another song because of the short notice.

“It takes a lot of time and effort to find a song, get it arranged, have everyone memorize their part and polish it all to have it performance-ready,” Kim said.

JMU said they decided to ban Christian songs from the celebration because administrators did not want to promote a specific religion at a public university event.

“JMU is a public university, so because it was a school-sponsored event, the song choice needed to be secular,” said Bill Wyatt, JMU’s senior director of communications and university spokesman. “The university made the decision to only sing secular songs. SGA [Student Government Association] merely helps the university coordinate the details.”

“Since this was a social gathering, all of the university’s a cappella groups were invited to perform one of several pre-selected, winter-themed songs,” Wyatt told Campus Reform.

According to WHSV, the SGA says the celebration began as a religious ceremony in the 1930s and it was unsure when the celebration became secular.

The university also named the celebration “Unity Tree Lighting” rather than “Christmas Tree Lighting” in order to bring all members of the school community together.

“It wasn’t a Christmas celebration,” Wyatt said. “It was an event intended to bring the community together in a celebration of community.”

According to Wyatt, JMU didn’t call the event a “Christmas Tree Lighting” because they were not lighting a Christmas Tree, despite the resemblance of the tree to a traditional Christmas tree.

Holiday Unity Tree JMU

On Sunday evening, two days after the “Unity Tree Lighting,” students on campus hosted the university’s first menorah lighting to kick off Hanukkah celebrations.

According to The Breeze, the Student Government Association provided the JMJews Chabad, the on-campus group that hosted the event, $2,150 to fund the lighting. The 12-foot tall menorah was lit using a large flaming torch called a shamash.

“A lot of people noticed that there’s not a menorah on campus, and while we do have the Unity Tree, a lot of people want to be unified by something that’s familiar to them,” Kara Kwart, president of the JMJews Chabad, said.

Kim disagreed with the university’s decision to ban Christian songs and said her a cappella group felt excluded at an event that was intended to promote unity.

“Unity is supposed to represent everyone,” Kim said. “As a Christian, I don’t feel represented.”

Into Hymn decided not to perform at the tree lighting. The group posted a statement on its Facebook page on Saturday morning explaining why.

Screen Shot 2015-12-07 at 10.19.59 PM

Into Hymn Facebook page

The views expressed in this opinion article are solely those of their author and are not necessarily either shared or endorsed by

About the author

Campus Reform

Campus Reform

Campus Reform, a project of the Leadership Institute, is America's leading site for college news.
As a watchdog to the nation's higher education system, Campus Reform exposes bias and abuse on the nation's college campuses.
Our team of professional journalists works alongside student activists and student journalists to report on the conduct and misconduct of university administrators, faculty, and students.
Campus Reform holds itself to rigorous journalism standards and strives to present each story with accuracy, objectivity, and public accountability.

Join the conversation!

We have no tolerance for comments containing violence, racism, vulgarity, profanity, all caps, or discourteous behavior. Thank you for partnering with us to maintain a courteous and useful public environment where we can engage in reasonable discourse.

Send this to a friend